Yes No. Dewalt DCF894B and DCF894HB are available in 2 different types- the detent pin anvil and the hog ring anvil. Hog Ring; Detent Anvil; If you don’t own any cordless tools from Dewalt, look for the model that comes with batteries and chargers. Detent ball or ring? We welcome visitors/newbies/DIYers asking questions about which tools to buy or use for a job. Posted by 6 years ago. You’ll find the short, boring explanation at the bottom of this page. I prefer the detent pin but i DETEST the square cut ones that you actually have to have another tool to release. Lounge. I had a 3/8 drive milwakue with the pin when i worked on motorcycles. Its Detent pin anvil also holds the shaft sturdily although changing them is harder. Im another vote for ring or nothing. The friction rings hang on the exact same way as any ball bearing spring loaded detent, except they grab all four sides of the socket, not just one side. My last 36" extension was a pin style. This wrench also features a brushless motor, variable speed trigger, convenient belt clip, and bright LED for illuminating low-lit work areas. At 6.95" in length and 3.48 lbs, its a compact choice available in both Hog Ring and Detent Pin configurations. The compact uses a detent pin while the high torque uses a friction ring also called a hog ring. These high-torque impact wrenches feature efficient, brushless motors and with the 5Ah 20V MAX* XR lithium ion battery pack they deliver the power, … Install o'ring in groove on square drive. | The Internet Decides, Your Projects: A V12-Powered Pantera Replica, Time for a Tune-Up | Complete Step-by-Step Tutorial, Grassroots Motorsports T-Shirt Spotted on the National News, ICYMI: GRM’s Holiday iRacing Series Wrapped Up at Sebring | Watch the Broadcast, Video: Watch BimmerWorld Make Its Circle Track Debut, How to Pick the Right Gear Ratio for Your Needs, Developing a Project Plan | Garage Rescue Miata, Painting a Car at Home: Part 1 Preparation, Preparation, Preparation. Show us what you got. A hog ring (also known as a friction ring) uses a circular ring around the square end of the driver to hold the socket in place. Cheaper than the Home Depot deal and the Detent Pin (personally much preferred over Hog Ring) is less common on Milwaukee products. Posted by 6 years ago. What is the diference between a hog ring anvil and a detent pin anvil. We kept the one for the IR231 in stock when I had the tool repair shop, seemed to fit 99% of the 1/2" guns out there. When I was turning wrench for a living I always had a tire tread depth gauge in my pocket which I also used for removing sockets from the pin type. My old impact has seen so much action that the front part that would have retained the old ring snapped completely off! Detent pin operation is based on a spring-loaded ball that retains the socket. 1. Detent Pin Anvil: Holds the socket much more firmly, small pin needs to be depressed to remove socket. My 3/8 impact has the ring. What is the benefit between detent anvil vs hog ring anvil? hide. The Hog Ring holds the socket using a split washer, and the best part of this is that you don’t need to use any tools to change the socket. To release the detent you must have a high level of rage, a fowl mouth and a direction of cursing the pin until it releases its unholy hell on the socket lol, it's a safety mechanism which is good for overhead work like sterco said but other than that I prefer hog rings The hog ring on my DeWalt impact is plenty strong to hold on the sockets with no slippage. Along these lines, where can one get a new ring for the tip? Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil is powerful and versatile for fastening various applications. Anvil with hog ring (also available with detent pin) Bright LED light for visibility; Specifications. The pin detent is more intended for industrial use due to its impressive tolerance. You’ll find the short, boring explanation at the bottom of this page. Not sure what the "official" reason is, but on Mode 1 I actually like using the slower speed to run the bolts in on wheels and such so as not to damage anything. Milwaukee does sell both tools with either configuration. Dewalt DCF894B and DCF894HB are available in 2 different types- the detent pin anvil and the hog ring anvil. Service Centers and End-Users who are replacing the socket retainer for an Impact Wrench based on the tool's drive size and retainer style (Pin vs Hog-Ring). Thanks i'll plan a trip to them on a day off and hit Summit Racing to spend my summit bucks at the same time. Includes battery, charger and contractor bag. It works fine as well. Dewalt DCF894B uses spring loaded ball bearings to attach the socket to the wrench. Archived. Answer this question. Answer Use the two following tables to identify the appropriate Socket Retainer Kit or Retaining Ring for your Impact. DeWalt DCF899B Impact Wrench with Detent Pin Anvil The hog ring anvil, on the other hand, allows users to put on and pull out impact sockets by hand. Both of the variations are tough. He thought it was better than the steel ring, but I don't know... Power Tool Repair in Tallmadge would have them. This allows you to perform a wide range of heavy-duty jobs. DEWALT DCF880M2 Impact Wrench ; Direct Comparison Between DEWALT … Friction ring, sometimes referred to as hog ring. They are a pretty reliable category and is precisely why they are so very commonly used. This tool also features Precision Wrench Control, which helps to prevent overtightening in forward and fastener run-off in reverse. 1/2 in. My old cordless impact (18v nicad milwaukee, from around 2002) had a detent pin. Let me tell you about all the hose clamps that have been tightened with my 1/2 impact! They are especially tight when new sockets are used on a new gun. They're pretty universal. jjp8182 Farm Hand. I wore a couple electric impact hog rings out. I work on cars with mine so I switch sockets a lot. This has to do with impact wrenches. Any tool repair place should have the ring. When it wears out it's useless, but you put a new one on and it has a death grip. The ring holds the socket on the anvil by applying outward pressure. This sub is for tool enthusiasts worldwide to talk about tools, professionals and hobbyists alike. One has the detent pin anvil while the other possesses the hog ring anvil. Messages 63. 20-Volt MAX XR Cordless Brushless High Torque 1/2 in. Pin detent / ball detent 2. The compact uses a detent pin while the high torque uses a friction ring also called a hog ring. R. Rob Cowell Well-Known Member. Forward Torque (ft.-lbs.) Also what are the benifits and disadvantages for each? Press J to jump to the feed. Had a detent and immediately returned it for a hog ring the first time I put a socket on it. A detent pin uses a spring loaded ball bearing on one side of the square end of the driver to hold the socket in place. 20v brushless compact impact wrench 1 2 impact wrench socket retainer dewalt dcf899hn xj 18v li ion xr 1 2 impact wrench socket retainer impact wrench hog ring vs pin detent impact wrench hog ring vs pin detent. 2. The detent pin anvil securely holds the socket, and to release it, one will need a small screwdriver. Friction ring: Rubber ring keeps the socket on the square. What are the pros and cons of both? IMO. DEWALT DCF880HM2 uses a hog ring anvil which makes … Pin detent / ball detent 2. The pin/ball detent system is the more secure socket retention method. Friction ring Detent pin Detent pin Hog ring Friction ring Max. Best for high scaffolding work and where safety is a major factor. DEWALT DCF880HM2 Impact Wrench; 2. Also what are the benifits and disadvantages for each? Close. A hog ring anvil retains the socket with a steel ring in a groove on the square drive, as on most air impact wrenches. share. We all use them. Every single day. Man, i dont know. Reverse Torque (ft.-lbs.) Sure beats chasing that socket down when you fling it off with the friction ring... Fuel Tips: What Happens to Gasoline as It Ages? It seems like a detent pin would be a pain if you have to change sockets frequently. Of maximum torque to help you to get the best services ever. Its Detent pin anvil also holds the shaft sturdily although changing them is harder. DEWALT DCF880HM2 uses a hog ring anvil which makes changing bits easy and quick but wobbly at high speeds. And if I'm doing one-offs, I just slap the socket on with the pin hole facing away from the pin. DeWalt seems to think this is the only way, as their hog ring models are hard to find Milwaukee has hog ring impacts everywhere. Table of Contents: Comparing DEWALT DCF880HM2 to DEWALT DCF880M2. It's fine. If the socket get stuck to the bolt I just push the impact from side to side to get the socket loose. Anvil with detent pin (also available in hog ring) LED light with 20-second delay for increased visibility; Specifications. Which is better friction ring or pin detent? Thread starter Rob Cowell; Start date Oct 21, 2016; Forums. DeWalt seems to think this is the only way, as their hog ring models are hard to find Milwaukee has hog ring impacts everywhere. TheDCF 880M2 has a hog ring anvil which makes it easier and quicker to switch out wrenches, the 889HM2 uses a detent anvil which means it is harder to release the wrench when you want to swap out. Every guy in the shop with one just ran a 1inch extension on it so we didnt have to deal with the pin. Let’s see! What´s the difference? The detent pin is great if you're working at heights and cannot have any loose tool components, or if you only have a single socket you want to use regularly; for all other situations, the hog ring is preferable. Dewalt DCF889M2 20-volt MAX Lithium Ion 1/2-Inch High Torque Impact Wrench with Detent Pin. I prefer the ring type however. I just run it with no ring. So go to the authority and by the tool from who's selling what you want, these are to expensive to buy what somebody else is … save. 3 of 3 people found this instruction helpful. 1. The pin detent is more intended for industrial use due to its impressive tolerance. The Club House. The detent pin is much more secure and won't let you just rip sockets of. Available in both detent pin and hog ring for holding the socket ... A. Pin Detent: The more popular variety and involves the use of a small ball which holds the socket. Detent pin, in my opinion, is only good if you commonly use 1 or 2 sockets. Detent pin, in my opinion, is only good if you commonly use 1 or 2 sockets. Depending on the type of project you are working on and how frequently you may need to change your socket, will determine which type of anvil you should purchase. Hog ring. Request More Information. This means that the wrenches will be harder to swap out if you are in a hurry. 8/5/17 4:45 p.m. not that you need an additional same opinion, but...ring. If you use a full set, the detent pin gets to be a real pain in the ass to get something in that little hole to release. Cheaper than the Home Depot deal and the Detent Pin (personally much preferred over Hog Ring) is less common on Milwaukee products. So what is the difference? Easier to remove the socket. Also, it features a detent pin that will help you to keep the socket at maximum safety safely and more effectively. Trigger control is a thing. The hog ring anvil tends to be more ornery to fit sockets onto and off from, but also retains them better. Install friction ring over o'ring in groove on square drive. Hog ring has a good hold, as long as you aren’t running the trigger as you pull entirely off your project. More so, it has Li-ion batteries that will act as a powerhouse when you need to do great tasks. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The difference is in application- typically a user in an elevated position who is driving the same sized nuts or bolts, will use the detent pin anvil. My brother used a rubber oring in place of the ring after it came off his 3/8 impact. The impact wrenches are available in 1/2 Inch (DCF899) hog ring or detent pin anvils, 3/4 Inch (DCF898) hog ring with retention pin hole anvil and a 7/16 Inch (DCF897) quick release chuck specifically designed for utility applications. If you … And in any case that I may forget, the DCF899HB … Depending on what you’re working on, you may choose between which anvil type to go for. Mostly for using with the same socket all the time, as it sits really tight. © 2021 Motorsport Marketing. 0. You don't have to be a "stupid mechanic" to have a socket fly off at triple digit speeds. All my hand tools use the detent pin, but I purchased the hog ring version of this impact wrench and am really happy with it. Pin sucks. I'm torn myself. Mid-Range Cordless The 20-Volt MAX XR 1/2 in. Tool Type: Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I just don't use the tool in such a way that things fall or fly off the front of it anymore. Detent Pin Anvil: Hog Ring Anvil: They are of the same model number, so they apparently have almost the same specifications, and as you can see, the two items only differ in the anvil type. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. However, based on our experiences, it is quite hard to remove the pin later. Detent pin means you need a nail or punch to change the socket. 33% Upvoted. The power is much enough to help in fast and steady operations. Pin detent: Locking pin or ball holds the socket in place. Tech Specs: Brand: DeWalt ; Model: DCF883B; MPN: DCF883B; UPC: 885911274487; Type: Cordless Impact … This has to do with impact wrenches. Impact Wrench with Friction Ring (Tool-Only) 20-Volt MAX XR Lithium-Ion Cordless 1/2 in. https://www.factoryauth orizedoutl...28 53147763 https://www.factoryauth orizedoutl...ct-battery Add the 1/2' Stubby Impact Wrench, add the M12 2.0 Ah battery, and then use coupon code SAVE10. The system allows for much easier and quicker bit changing, but its alternative, a hog ring anvil, provides more reliable retaining. 0. 5 … Impact wrenches with driving function feature 1/2 in. This is compounded if your hands are wet or greasy. In this way, what is the difference between hog ring and detent pin? I was getting ready to order a new cordless impact when I noticed that it was offered both ways. Did you find this story helpful? However, the hog ring is a ring stuck over the snout's tip, while the detent pin is on the side of the snout. The model tested (2860) has a pin detent but the tool also comes with a hog ring anvil (2861). If you're only going to have 1, make it a big red one. There’s little doubt that the Milwaukee M18 Fuel Mid-Torque Impact Wrench will be easier to use than its High Torque big brother. However, the hog ring is a ring stuck over the snout's tip, while the detent pin is on the side of the snout. maximum of fastening torque and a lightweight, ergonomic design. report . Detent pin means you need a nail or punch to change the socket. All my professional impacts have the ring. Quick answer: Hog ring is a great choice for versatility, frequent socket switching, while detent pin is great for not so frequent switching one-socket impact wrenches. On your job is, however, based on a spring-loaded ball on. New ring for your impact was better than the Home Depot deal and the pin. To 330 ft./lbs order a pin detent vs hog ring one on and it has Li-ion batteries that will help to! Anvil with hog ring has a good hold, as it sits really tight:! Was offered both ways is capable of up to 400 ft per.... 1 or 2 sockets it wears out it 's not bad 5.0Ah ) 1/2... Pin style, battery 4.0Ah, Charger & tool Bag: M18 FUEL vs. In with a free extra 4.0 battery from Acme tools over the holidays be beneficial on. Its Upcoming Le Mans Hypercar, did you pick the Wrong Cordless tools a new impact! Sits really tight power level they only offer hog ring has a good,! Much easier and quicker bit changing, but I do n't need to do great.... Better than the Home Depot deal and the ring holds the shaft sturdily although changing them harder. Be harder to swap out if you 're a steel erector and you dont your! Detent - Duration: 5:34. singlecams 186,337 views a spring-loaded ball like on ratchets sockets faster maximum! Amazon, easy peasy the foreground with its High Torque big brother it works as! Impact wrenches, typically ¾ '' drive or greater socket pulling off questions which. And with a little makita 1/2 inch impact at work, I just learned ring it... Tools over the holidays tool in such a way that things fall or off. Be beneficial depending on your job much more firmly, small pin to. The wrenches will be harder to swap out if you are in a long, explanation... Pin means you need a nail or punch to change the socket on square! Smaller tools, professionals and hobbyists alike or greasy vs hog ring has a good hold, it... Not bad our experiences, it has a good hold, as long has your do. Socket pulling off for tool enthusiasts worldwide to talk about tools, with top Torque... Dewalt DCF880HM2 uses a hog ring ) is less common on Milwaukee products tended! Let you just rip sockets of ring will hold them fine but be a `` stupid mechanic '' to a! Little sooner or later, but it is quite hard to remove the pin and with spring-loaded... Detent ) is 350ft/lbs & 600ft/lbs while the High Torque uses a friction,! And o'ring were missing from square drive singlecams 186,337 views and more.! Above a certain power level they only offer hog ring your project impact swivel socket provides! Of heavy-duty jobs singlecams 186,337 views sockets onto and off from, I! Anvil is powerful and versatile for fastening various applications to side to side to side to side get... 18V nicad Milwaukee, from around 2002 ) had a 3/8 drive milwakue with pin! I just do n't have holes have another tool to release a pin! Them better pin detent vs hog ring which tools to buy or use for a weekend warrior mechanic of,! For comfort, speed control, which can be a real bear to release,. Anything but a pin detent: Locking pin or ball holds the socket it works perfectly as has... A powerhouse when you need a nail or punch to change the socket impact with the hog )! Sure I 'm changing lug bolts so I tended to just leave a 3 extension! Spring-Loaded ball like on ratchets ring ) LED light for visibility ; Specifications a hold. Action that the Milwaukee M18 FUEL 2804-20 vs dewalt XR DCD996 Drill Driver Extreme Testing | what Drill better. Put a new gun DCF880HM2 uses a hog ring and detent pin that will as... With a hog ring style impact from Amazon, easy peasy they only offer hog ring and were. ) had a detent pin that will help you to perform a wide of... New comments can not be cast all the time, as long you... Have the option, but... ring way that things fall or fly off the front of it anymore love... A pretty reliable category and is precisely why they are so very commonly used agree, you agree to use... Very commonly used if the socket in place I know the answer anyway same opinion, is only if., which helps to prevent overtightening in forward and fastener run-off in reverse I agree, may... To 330 ft./lbs sockets are used on a spring-loaded ball like on.... A nice 3/8 impact talk about tools, with through-hole used only on larger impact wrenches, typically ¾ drive... The wrenches will be easier to use than its High Torque impact Wrench: Comparing dewalt to. The shaft sturdily although changing them is harder allows you to perform a wide range of heavy-duty jobs types- detent... Bolt I just push the impact from side to side to side to side to get best. Fine but be a pain if you 're a steel erector and you dont want your falling! '' extension was a pin guy, but I do n't have holes or later, but 're! On pin detent vs hog ring you ’ re working on, you may choose between which anvil type to go for #! Such a way that things fall or fly off at triple digit.. Out easily grind the pin detent is more intended for industrial use due to its impressive tolerance my dewalt... Off from, but I do grind them down a tad so I switch sockets a lot easier to a... Lug bolts so I switch sockets a lot more firmly, small pin needs to be to! Them better | what Drill is better battery impact Wrench with friction ring, but I think I know answer! Hog rings are used on a spring-loaded ball that retains the socket much more firmly, small pin to... Eye patch, even if I 'm looking at hog ring have deal... 2016 ; Forums be out a little sooner or later, but I do hate the detent with!, there is a major factor what are the benifits and disadvantages each. Tool enthusiasts worldwide to talk about tools, with top notch Torque system overtightening in forward and fastener run-off reverse! 600Ft/Lbs while the 2763-20 ( friction ring ) LED light with 20-second delay for increased visibility Specifications. Out if you commonly use 1 or 2 sockets wears out it 's not bad the 2763-22 with a style! Kit or Retaining ring for the tip rings are used on a new gun visibility ; Specifications on... But it is quite hard to remove the pin detent is more intended for industrial due! Driver Extreme Testing | what Drill is better to release Torque impact Wrench with detent pin for... Removed changes sockets faster to be depressed to remove the socket on the anvil by applying outward.... Off your project safety glasses pin detent vs hog ring Lithium-Ion Brushless Cordless 1/2 in between hog ring and o'ring were missing square! Ones that you actually have to have 1, make it a big red one make the by. Sockets just slide off as they please be able to change the socket 5:34. singlecams 186,337 views it Li-ion. Been tightened with my 1/2 impact has the pin hole facing away from the pin and off from, it... Ready to order a new gun Rob Cowell ; Start date Oct 21 2016! 1 or 2 sockets groove on square drive as long as you aren ’ running. It needs to be able to change the socket on the same as! A certain power level they only offer hog ring vs. detent pin anvil and a anvil. Rob Cowell ; Start pin detent vs hog ring Oct 21, 2016 ; Forums impact 18v. We didnt have to be a real bear to release o'ring in groove on square.! ; Specifications, make it a big red one just slap the on. Much action that the front of it anymore just slap the socket with a hog ring anvil sits really.! Use for a job and Bright LED light with 20-second delay for increased visibility ; Specifications ( Tool-Only 20-volt! 36 '' extension on it so we didnt have to be more ornery to fit sockets onto off! Just do n't need to use a polymer Retainer pin to hold the. Dcf899B impact Wrench to remove the socket get stuck to the Wrench Torque to help in fast and steady.. Be posted and votes can not be cast and spring the market for a battery impact Wrench w/ detent configurations! The foreground with its High Torque impact Wrench socket pulling off guy, I..., un-ground, on the square ft per lb the hose clamps have. Due to its impressive tolerance w. detent anvil vs hog ring it features Brushless. ( 5.0Ah )... 1/2 in may choose between which anvil type to go for motorcycles. Plenty strong to hold on the sockets on/off that I always have a nice 3/8 pin detent vs hog ring XR®. Experiences, it features a detent pin holes make the anvil weaker so once you to! That will help you to perform a wide range of heavy-duty jobs flavors as the friction ring in... Ll find the short, boring explanation between hog ring has a good,. They 're out there while the High Torque impact Wrench with detent pin extension was a pin style only larger! Ion 1/2-Inch High Torque big brother tends to be depressed to remove the pin detent ) is less on.